Michael Santicola: There's no evidence there that ties him to the crime. Frank Catroppa: Absolutely not. I have no idea. The case of a young teacher killed steps from her home, is still unsolved over three years later. It's possible. The report states that Rachael told police that Jeter was "once a student of hers," now a "friend," and they were just talking. During jury selection, she revealed she was in the process of divorcing a distant relative of Jeter, too. On May 28, 2019, the felony charges against Joe Perciavalle for allegedly sending an obscene text to 17-year-old Lauren Watkins were dropped. Michael Santicola: I'm sure. Uh-huh [affirms]. The crime was discovered after firefighters responded to the scene of a house fire. After supper, Rachael went for ice cream with friends. The victim was approximately 52 tall with medium brown hair and two small circular birthmarks on her face. Someone anonymously emailed and texted the incident report to Rachael's school, the local school board, the media and the mayor. warren community center swim lessons. Not long after that weekend, Catroppa says Rachael became paranoid. Michael Santicola: I'm saying that her story doesn't make sense. So They'd see each other when they could. Please enter valid email address to continue. Her murder is still unsolved today, but Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier says the investigation is active. After the release of the report, Rachael was finally finished with Frank, but Lisa wasn't. This transaction was recorded by paper records and video surveillance. Her murder is still unsolved today, but Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier says the investigation is active. CIRCUMSTANCES: A teenage boy who was playing in the area found the dismembered remains of a full-term pregnant female. Chief Joe Perciavalle: --sent it out. That was like our thing. Joe DelTondo: I think I would've heard it I was right in that chair where I always am. He says it was an accident and meant for someone else. Frank Catroppa: You know, I was more confused than anything. All that was also released in the cyber blast. LOCATION: Along the banks of the Lehigh River in East Side Borough, Carbon County. Lisa DelTondo, Rachael's mother, believes Sheldon Jeter was involved in her daughter's murder. Frankie didn't wanna do that. To date there have been no confirmed sightings or contacts with Ray Gricar. On November 10, 1994, Rod Hager was shot in the back while outside laying concrete block; building his garage at his residence located along Nices Hollow Road, Porter Township, Lycoming County. Frank Catroppa: She contacted me and saying that, you know, that people were bothering her or the, you know police --. ", It had been a little over 10 months since Rachael DelTondo and Frank Catroppa called off their engagement, but the final chapter of their relationship was still being written. Lisa DelTondo bought her daughter a $10,000 wedding dress and a pair of $3,000 shoes. Sheldon's attorney insists it's not his client's fault that cops picked up the wrong clothes. Lauren Watkins [shakes her head no]: I did not. Dark blonde hair, Eyes: Blue/Wears glasses Michelle was last seen wearing: blue jeans, wine colored V-neck sweater, gold necklace with a "knot" pendant. All callers remain anonymous and could be eligible for a CASH REWARD. As winter turned into spring of 2018, Rachael DelTondo was trying hard to put her fears behind her. Wells' change purse was on the ground by the car, money still inside. authorities in Perry County, Pa. charged a local man with the 1983 murder of his wife. Erin Moriarty: Why are you texting someone who's sitting right behind you? The deceased male became a "John Doe" and was laid to rest at Longwood Cemetery in an unmarked grave where he remained unidentified for 44 years. That's probably why Rachael's former fianc, Frank Catroppa, was one of the first people questioned by police. They're following me.'". When they were together and happy on a Tuesday, they could have been broken up and miserable by Sunday [laughs]. And I said, "I'm gonna ask you two -- two questions." Steve Colafella is Catroppa's lawyer. The Beaver County Times reports that a judge last week sentenced Samuel to 30-year-to-life terms to be served consecutively, or an aggregate sentence of 60 years to life. I'm not a city official. Hometown of Jimmy Stewart, Indiana Pennsylvania. Upon arrival the officer found Stephanie Coyle on her bedroom floor. One. Erin Moriarty: As you sit here, do you believe that Frank Catroppa had to have at least been involved? Frank Catroppa: I wouldn't say that I was angry. Jen Glovan: She was bawling, hysterically crying, you know, shaking. Chief Joe Perciavalle: I told the chief I didn't feel comfortable givin' it to him. Whatever the truth, Catroppa was able to read the report that day, and it didn't quite match the story that Rachael had told him. On July 29, 2009, in an effort to further the investigation, members of the Pennsylvania State Police, Criminal Investigation Assessment/Missing Persons Unit, with assistance from the Chester County District Attorney's Office and Chester County Coroner's Office, exhumed John Doe's body. I could tell. Rachael had become socially isolated. Callers can anonymously contact the Beaver County Crime Solvers at 724-774-2000. Lisa DelTondo: She said, "We're goin' to Hanks to get ice cream." Jen Glovan: She wanted to get married and she wanted to have kids. Michael Santicola: There's only one person that got her outside her house, and that was Ms. Watkins. A college student then discovered him a few days later, yet he too waited a day before reporting it. boeing 767 patriot express. Lisa DelTondo: She couldn't sleep. On the evening of May 13, 2018, Mother's Day, Rachael's protector, Bolton, was out of town and Rachael decided to go out with Lauren. She is not here for me to hug and kiss and love, not here. And the chief told me, give it to him. So, Frank went to the Aliquippa Police Department and asked Assistant Police Chief Joe Perciavalle if there was an incident report. An autopsy determined that he had been stabbed once through the heart. Chief Joe Perciavalle: Just put it on there just in case somebody came. This month, investigators announced thatDNA evidence and advances in technology enabled them to create a composite drawing of the man who killed her. Missing since: February 11, 2004, from Lake Township, Luzerne County, PA, White/Female, DOB: 01/05/1982, 22 years old, Height: 5'6", Weight: 110 lbs., Hair: light brown, Eyes: Blue. Lita Wolf and Diane Wolf had ended their shift at Hanover Foods Inc. 1550 York Street, Hanover, PA. Asst. Erin Moriarty: But why? Jurors last month. The 25-year-old school teacher had been beaten, strangled and sexually assaulted. Samuel was convicted of. On Monday, September 18, 1972, Morgan Walters Peters Jr. was found lying in a small gully; face down approximately 55 feet north of the north edge of the Pennsylvania Turnpike, in the area of milepost 189.2. Perciavalle says that's because he heard about the encounter months after it happened, and although police found no evidence that Rachael had engaged in improper behavior, the assistant chief wanted a record of the event. Jackie Belcastro | Rachael's aunt: I know my Rachael was afraid of them. I'm not a government official. Chief Joe Perciavalle: I asked if they did a report. So, Percivalle says he first refused to give it to Catroppa. And if you look at the way this girl was shot and if you look at the close range that she was shot, this was somebody who was comfortable with a gun somebody that did not waiver, did not have emotion involved in this. Ask her what she was doing in the car with some kid at night." She says she never knew Rachael and Sheldon to have any type of romantic relationship and never once heard her friend say she was afraid of him. Lisa DelTondo: But the point is, she's still not here. He had messaged me on Facebook and was like, "Did I just pass you guys." On February 11, 2004, between 11:30 p.m. - 12:00 a.m. she finished her shift at the Pump-N-Pantry. Lynn and Dale had been shot; it is believed the fire was set by the unknown suspect(s) to destroy evidence. She texted: "go for a walk ill come pick you up after." Her assassination remains unsolved, but Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier says the inquiry is ongoing. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. ", with the help of CBS station KDKA consumer reporter Marty Griffin. . Him and Chief Couch was good friends, I guess. Nothing to do with Sheldon. All callers remain anonymous and could be eligible for a CASH REWARD. Erin Moriarty: But who did send it to you? Catroppa's attorney would not confirm whether Catroppa is the subject of a grand jury investigation, and it's unclear exactly what he would be investigated for. John Paul: Certainly, they shined a light in a place that was very dark -- that a lot of people felt wasn't even a place worth bother looking at. It was going to be their jury., Santicola agreed to forgo asking about the high-profile DelTondo case to avoid creating problems that didnt exist.. Frank DelTondo: There was no ill intent. I mean it went back and forth a lot. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. On April 15, 2005, Ray Gricar did not go to the office but phoned his paramour at approximately 11:30 a.m., and advised her he was taking a drive in the Penns Valley area of Centre County, on State Route 192. I wasn't gonna text back and be like, "Who's this?". I'm not doing drugs." The Pennsylvania State Police, Criminal Investigation Assessment Unit, Troop, K, Philadelphia, continues their investigation into the homicide of Denise Sharon Kulb. Sheldon Jeter Jr.'s uncle, Michael Moreland, says Sheldon was home the night Rachael DelTondo was killed. Lisa DelTondo: That night, I knew it was him. When "48 Hours" asked, officials wouldn't confirm or deny whether Frank Catroppa is a person of interest in Rachael's murder or whether he, Sheldon Jeter or anyone else has been cleared. The former Aliquippa football players conviction carried a mandatory life prison sentence. Remember, they also turned their attention to Frank Catroppa, who was dating someone new when Rachael was murdered. Tire Collection Events. It was higher than in 67.6% U.S. cities. Me and my brother look very much alike, so when I look at myself I cant help but to see him. Erin Moriarty: Did Sheldon Jeter see you? So, she kinda wanted to kinda paint me in a bad light at times. Erin Moriarty [at the lot]: You obviously come here not to be seen. The Pennsylvania State Police, Troop G, Lewistown, continue their investigation into the Homicide of Orie Donald Esh, that occurred at his residence located at 271 Kansas Road, Oliver Township, Mifflin County, PA. On September 6, 2001, at approximately 10:17 a.m., the victim Orie Donald Esh was found deceased inside his residence. Frank Catroppa: Yeah. The 11-year-old girl who disappeared in 1986 while walking home after visiting her mother in the hospital. 2019 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Karen Denise Wells, a 24-year-old single mother from Oklahoma, disappeared after checking into a motel room in Middlesex Township in Cumberland County on April 12, 1994. . During last months verdict, a courtroom spectator from Aliquippa recognized one of the jurors as a neighbor of DelTondo. Sheldon Jeter Jr. was arrested for the murder of Tyric Pugh just two days later and charged with criminal homicide. Less than four minutes after Lauren says she drove off, Rachael wound up dead not by the side door of her house, but all the way at the foot of her driveway.