The Oakland Raiders were playing the New England Patriots, whose quarterback was Tom Brady. terumiarai says: @tombradyfumbled But on replay, Carey said it was an incomplete pass because of the tuck rule. This weekend, ESPN will debut "The Tuck Rule," a "documentary" in the sense that it's a series of real people discussing, dissecting and squabbling over a real historical event the fateful. But the rule, while it . https://t.co/0qXIiq5Ux9, Brady said, "The Tuck Rule game against the Raiders," then looked around as if to make sure no one was listening, adding, "might have been a fumble. After this game, Mike Pereira, the former NFL vice-president for officiating, stated that he was no longer in support of the tuck rule.[6]. The Tuck rule should have never came into play. joesixpack doesnt know what a fumble is either. Two games later, the Patriots won Super Bowl XXXVI. The Raiders went to the Super Bowl the next year, but were beaten by Gruden's Buccaneers, 4821 and the Raiders did not make the playoffs again until 2016. In most cases where the Tuck Rule has been applied, the call would have been a fumble in those other associations. Plain and simple. But now Pereira says the rule needs to be scrapped. A. Bitch!. These situations should have been ruled fumbles all alongthe tuck rule has caused unnecessary controversy. https://ftw.usatoday.com/2017/01/nfl-tuck-rule-game-new-england-patriots-oakland-raiders-what-if, that brilliant Super Bowl game plan he devised for the Rams, his game plan for Super Bowl XXV against the Bills is actually in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, 2023 NFL Combine Winners Day 2: It's (another) bumper crop of cornerback talent, LaDainian Tomlinson's nephew going through drills at the combine is sure to make you feel old, 17 NFL greats who were terrible at the scouting combine, Where to watch the NFL Combine, live stream, TV channel, Defensive Backs, The Bears have a smart reason for playing darts and mini golf in their NFL combine interviews, A Seinfeld clip was brilliantly used to analyze John Lynch's body language for Trey Lance talk, The Red Sox found a loophole in the MLB shift ban and it stinks for Joey Gallo, The Warriors left Russell Westbrook ridiculously wide open and it worked to perfection, Survivor 44: Meet the castaways who will compete for $1 million in Fiji, Watch: Man tries feeding bison near Yellowstone; it doesnt go well, 2023 NFL Combine Winners Day 1: Blazing-fast DTs give the Bears plenty to consider, Ranking all 32 NFL teams' helmet logos, from worst to best, How bald eagles really sound (it's not like in the movies), Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Everyone acts like they didnt drive down the field and have Vinatieri kick one of the most difficult field goals in league history, followed by driving down the field in OT to get another score. Is the tuck rule, on the other hand, still in effect? By taking the hit, the Patsies also got to see what the Raiders were doing defensively. I am truly staggered by the impeccable logic and flawless analytical acumen demonstrated by your post. Your explanations for years were at best inconsistent. The tuck rule had been on the books for years, . In this case, they clearly took a victory away from the Raiders. This is referred to as the tuck rule because the ball leaving the quarterback's hands is considered a forward pass even if the quarterback intends not to pass the ball, but instead continues the forward motion to tuck the ball back into his body. Brady, who recently announced his retirement, is now a seven-time Super Bowl champion who . Its called a clue. Get over it, pathetic Raiders fans. . But its not as if St. Louis would have replaced New England as the NFLs most successful organization. The tuck rule was enforced in a regular season game on October 9, 2005, between the Washington Redskins and the Denver Broncos. Incomplete pass? US AGAINST THE MEDIA The thing that makes no sense is is that the refs had to have been 100% certain that when Brady brought the ball in it did not touch his other hand. But..the reversal was the correct call at the time, because thats the way the rule was written then, and thats the way the rule still reads today. PRIDE AND POISE RAIDER NATION Coleman's announcement stated that the ball was moving forward at the time at which it was dropped. And even Marshall Faulk started to decline after that 2001 season. In 1999, a new rule had been introduced, which eventually became known as the tuck rule: NFL Rule 3, Section 22, Article 2, Note 2. We prevented your team (assuming you would have beat the steelers ((big assumption by the way)) ) from embaressing yourselves for two consecutive superbowls. In week 2 of the NFL season in 2001. The hit that time came from Tony Bryant rather than Charles Woodson. [9] On September 23, Patriots defensive end Anthony Pleasant apparently forced Jets quarterback Vinny Testaverde to fumble,[10] but the call was overturned upon review and ruled an incomplete pass. The rule has been derided, but the call itself, was to the letter of the rule. Tom Brady fumbled and the NFL would not let the dreaded Raiders win. The Tuck Rule has changed the careers of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick forever . By Pereiras estimate, its been called 120-150 times since it was called in the Raiders-Patriots playoff game (see 2005 story linked in my earlier post) and many times before then, so every team has experienced it MULTIPLE TIMES, though admittedly with lesser importance than that famous instance. Of course, I think downing the football to save the clock should also be ruled intentional grounding, since it is exactly what is taking place. I said might. Great games shouldnt come down to a obscure rule that when seen by the human eye at games speed LOOKS LIKE A FUMBLE EVERY TIME! "The Tuck Rule" changed Tom Brady's career. Oakland kneels on the ball and kills the clock. Moreover, you Patsy fans will say let it go because it was years ago now, and yet, when the Tuck Rule happened, you all immediately called it justice for the Ben Dreith game. As a Raider fan, I have a different take on the matter. raidernationabby the rule is correct. [1] Broncos quarterback Jake Plummer lost the football while in the Broncos' own end zone. What channel is the NFL Network on Time Warner Cable? Tom Brady has won 35 postseason games, by far the most in NFL history. The refs missed that play completely. Dont let the damn lawyers write the rules anymore. Patriots should have had 1st and 10 with an extra 15 yards. It was a snowy day at Foxboro Stadium. No team was beating the Rams that year without a game plan devised by Belichick. The 106 Oakland Raiders were the #3 seed and had beaten the Jets in an AFC wild card game, 3824. (GIF) : nfl. It prohibits runners and defenders from lowering their heads and striking a forcible blow with. First of all, I agree, its time for the ruled to be changed! Commentary on this game did not end after the season, the "Tuck Rule Game" has been debated since, with many, possibly even Brady, calling it a fumble. Pereira sucks everytime he says how a challenge will go the ref comes out and does something completely different I dont care for that guy, WELL SAID theandy59 Im age 52 and watched that game myself Then the refs had the gall to add two unsportsman penalties, putting the ball on the five yard line, when in fact the game should have been over. I read an article saying that the wrong call was made Sure enough on certain angles you can see woodsons open hand swipe at the ball and missing. I have a very simple solution to this absurd rule: When the defender hits the QB, if the ball hits the ground behind the line of scrimmage it's a fumble. So get over it, Charles Woodson. If the Raiders were that great how come they couldnt stop the Pats on one of the following plays ? I know who else was disappointed that the Patriots didnt beat the Raiders in 1976The Minnesota VikingsThey might have finally won a Super Bowl if they had been playing the Patriots instead of the Raiders that year. Raiders were the best team in the NFL from 2000-2003 WOULD OF BEEN LONGER PERHAPS IF IT WASNT FOR THAt SCUMBAG! I question the existence of the Tuck Rule. When [an offensive] player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward movement of his arm starts a forward pass, even if the player loses possession of the ball as he is attempting to tuck it back toward his body. mrconnors says: Brady began a passing motion, but then ceased, before tucking the ball with his left hand. Luke Straub. Afterwards, referring obliquely to the 2002 Tuck Rule Game, Patriots owner Robert Kraft said, "I love the tuck rule, and forever will, and I know [longtime Raiders owner] Al Davis, may he rest in peace, is probably smiling. An existing rule was strengthened as a result of this. (Gruden would return to the Raiders in 2018 after spending a stint as a broadcaster with ESPN.). Brady posted his confession on social media, rekindling a. Dont fix what aint broke. A pass should only be ruled incomplete if the ball comes loose in the actual act of passing the ball. Is Tom Brady the same great quarterback without that first Super Bowl win? The Tom Brady rule states that a defender on the ground who has not been pushed into the quarterback cannot lunge at a quarterbacks knee or lower legs. When [an offensive] player is holding the ball to pass it forward, any intentional forward movement of his arm starts a forward pass, even if the player loses possession of the ball as he is attempting to tuck it back toward his body. During ESPN's new 30 for 30 documentary called, "The Tuck Rule", the future Hall of Fame quarterback admitted that if he didn't lead the New. "The five most significant plays in recent NFL history", "The NFL's 10 Greatest Postseason Games of the 2000s", "NFL rescinds 'tuck rule' The Boston Globe", "New York Jets at New England Patriots - September 23rd, 2001 - Pro-Football-Reference.com", "Holy Tuck: An oral history of the Raiders-Patriots Tuck Rule Game, which 15 years ago forever altered the NFL", "Best kick ever? RAIDERS WILL BE BACK. lets 1)reinvent the rule book in the playoffs; 2) use the reinvention to OVERTURN the call on the field; 3) reward a qb who got made a fool out of on the play, and; 4) nullify an excellent defensive play. [17], Up to his retirement at the end of the 2018 season, Coleman officiated 265 more NFL games, including 21 more involving the Patriots, but none involving the Raiders. That set the tone for two more Raiders Super Bowl victories in the following decade. Brown fumbled the ball at the end of the return, but Pats linebacker Larry Izzo recovered it with 2:06 left on the clock. The Patsies got lucky, because otherwise, the game would have ended right there. Both teams struggled in the heavy snowstorm during the first half, combining for the same number of punts as first downs (11) and converting only one of 13 third downs. If it comes loose in the tucking motion, then it should be a fumble.. if 50 guys at the bar think it's a fumble, then it's a fumble. Bill Belichick should have to insult three teams in a season, one must be in the AFC East. I love how people give the raiders so much attention. I love how people act like the Pats won against the Raiders only because of the tuck rule. Brady played in the 2000 Thanksgiving game @ Detroit, so this wasn't his first game. January 16, 2019 10:09 pm PT. Where is the arm at that point? It's been 10 years since the infamous tuck rule game, and the rule itself reared its ugly . Never mind. [3] The call was overturned upon review and ruled an incomplete pass, with the tuck rule cited. Many feel it was a controversial play that allowed New England to move on, win their first Super Bowl and set the tone for all that have accomplished since. (This was also the game in which Patriots quarterback Drew Bledsoe was injured by a hit from Mo Lewis, giving backup Tom Brady a chance to play.) The Patriots should never had got that first Super Bowl. i cant help but wonder how many patriots fans that have posted here about how right that tuck rule call was would be ticked off if the shoe was on the other foot and the raiders had been the ones to retain possession. QBs dont deserve a free pass. Bullshit. at I might be better off looking it up. You guys amaze me with your stupid rule book bs. Now to take a look at this play and the impact it had, let's take a time machine back to 2002. Because I find it laughable to be told let it go by New England fans. On the opening drive of the third quarter, he connected with David Patten for gains of 25 and 19 yards as he led the Patriots 62 yards in 12 plays to the Raiders' 5-yard line, where Adam Vinatieri made a 23-yard field goal to make it 73. They had already lost in the playoffs and Mike Pereira and his crew of crooked and biased referees can go straight to hell for their ignorance! Let's look at some more examples of Tuck Rule-type plays from last season with a prediction of how they will be called in 2013. Thats what happened. It completely cheated the Raiders out of a title run. - Also, if the player has tucked the ball into his body and then loses possession, it is a fumble.". if i was a raiders fan my bedroom would look like finkels and my mother certainly wouldnt be giving out cookies at the door. Knowing what we now know about Belichick, is there any chance he was turning down a first-round pick from the Bills and the opportunity to shed the richest contract in NFL history? The 2001 AFC Divisional Playoff game between the New England Patriots and the Oakland Raiders, also known as the Tuck Rule Game or the Snow Bowl,[2][3] or sometimes referred to as Snow Bowl 2, took place on January 19, 2002, at Foxboro Stadium in Foxborough, Massachusetts, which was at the time the Patriot's home stadium. Its all very fascinating but a tremendous waste of time. On fourth down and 4 from the Raiders' 28, Brady hit Patten for a six-yard completion. Dont let revisionist history fool you: This wasnt some great Oakland team that was destined to win it all. He's allowed only two challenges per game, but if both challenges are successful, he's given a third. Sometimes you have to look past the ignorant fans and complex rationalizations they come up with and watch the damn play. Cassells was the real tuck rule. Brady has six championship rings and nine total Super Bowl appearances, the most of any player in history. But then, they wont have anything to whine about for the next ten years. According to the exact wording of the rule, when a quarterback goes to pass the football, his hand is considered in throwing motion until the ball is completely stopped or pulled down in attempt to begin a run. Terry Kirby returned the ensuing kickoff 22 yards to the Oakland 37-yard line and the Raiders produced a 10-play, 43-yard drive to score on a 38-yard field goal from Sebastian Janikowski. Thirdly and finally, all you raider hacks owe every new englander a thank you! Buy Raiders Tickets. However, in the fourth quarter, Brady led the Patriots on a 10-play, 67-yard drive, completing nine consecutive passes for 61 yards and finishing it with a 6-yard touchdown run with 7:57 left that made the score 1310. Raiders fans wont be happy until anti-incest laws are repealed. An incomplete pass stops the clock and prevents the loss of yards from a sack. philadelphia parking authority customer service phone number. Tom Brady, after proving himself to the Patriots in 2001, gets the full time starting job still.The Pats would be a winning team throughout the decade, going as low as 8-8 to as high as 12-4. ", The seven-time Super Bowl champion then backtracked, quote tweeting his video saying, "I said might. You state that Tom Brady suffered a blow to the head from Charles Woodson on the play which should have been a penalty on the Raiders. st mary's academy paducah, ky how many times has the tuck rule been called The 2,957 yards rushing was the fifth-highest total in NFL history at the time. Please explain Einstein how you can have an incomplete pass without first throwing the football? Photos (and replay) clearly show Brady with both hands on the ball before its knocked out. Backup quarterback Tom Brady then led the offense to a playoff berth. If we would have gotten the call the way it should have been, the Patriots would have never drove down and tied the game up, thus no overtime drive, and again no field-goal. Officials overturned the fumble call, invoking the Tuck Rule, which currently says that if a quarterback has started his arm forward for a forward pass, even if he loses control of the ball. Then, after a 33-yard punt by Walter gave the Raiders a first down on their own 49, a 22-yard reception by receiver Jerry Rice set up Janikowski's second field goal, from 45 yards, giving the Raiders a 133 lead with two minutes left in the third quarter. Except for two things. Now he tells us! Not happening. I was young and didn't watch football at the time. [14] Patriots owner Robert Kraft noted that Al Davis was probably looking down from the afterlife and happy that the rule had been abolished. 3 trillion in assets under management, as of March 31, 2022, the most recently available information. 2 The 'tuck rule' became famous after a New England vs Oakland showdown in 2002 Credit: AFP From 1999 to 2013, the National Football League used the tuck rule, which was a contentious rule in American football. Exactly! Impossible. Pereira said in 2005 that the rule comes up in games about 12 to 15 times per season, so it shouldnt be just associated with the Patriots-Raiders play. The ruling made the game exceptionally hard to referee, as well as giving a big advantage to the quarterback. I've heard it as week 2 and also your later game against the Jets. With under a minute remaining in regulation time, Patriots' placekicker Adam Vinatieri kicked a 45-yard field goal to tie the game at 13, sending the game into overtime. It would be the same as saying when a QB is handing off to a RB and the ball comes out, the QB is technically passing the ball to the RB so it should be an incomplete pass, also. Roughing the passer? Someone should let the Raider fans know their pathetic defense had about 20 more chances to stop the Patriots on that amazing night. Well, folks, The Bussy Contingency has been activated. If the player loses possession of the ball during an attempt to bring it back toward his body, or if the player loses possession after he has tucked the ball into his body, it is a fumble. Wow. [1], The tuck rule was also enforced in an NFL playoff game on January 9, 2011, between the Kansas City Chiefs and the Baltimore Ravens. He then rushed to his sideline and told his team what he had heard. No waitMost likely the Steelers would have thrashed the Patriots in the AFC Championship gameOh well. Please check the opt-in box to acknowledge that you would like to subscribe. I agree to receive the "Pick Six Newsletter" and marketing communications, updates, special offers (including partner offers), and other information from CBS Sports and the Paramount family of companies. How about this for a rule: you lose the ball it is a fumble. I've brought it up before and gotten downvoted. @tooz56 While the Patriots were slightly out of field-goal range, Brady dropped back to pass, with no open receivers. Raiders middle linebacker Greg Biekert then fell on the loose football. The tuck rule was an exception to this rule. You can't see the line of scrimmage on the field. Okay, now that this is figured out, what about spiking the football? Losing on a fluke (and possibly bad) call is much more palatable than getting blown out. I think its time to change this rule, Pereira writes at FOXSports.com. Stay classyAwesome post (especially like you putting god in your postMind you it was a little g since you are probably a church going man). Well it's not a rule any more so problem solved. They all need to be replaced and as far away from a football game as possible if they cant see thats a fumble. Wikipedia's page for your 2001 season says the latter, but your image above shows home jerseys (week two). The Raiderswent 10-6 and would have had to go on the road to Pittsburgh against the No. After he had begun a passing motion, Brady clearly ceased his throwing motion, pulled his right hand down below his shoulder and had touched the ball to his left hand when, coming off the strong side corner blitz, Charles Woodson knocked the ball out of Brady's hands. If a QB stops his throwing motion and starts to protect the ball. What time do NFL fantasy waivers go through? Now if you could just pick up a first down on 3rd and 1, the Pats never get it back in the first place. But on replay, Carey said it was an incomplete pass because of the tuck rule. The Jets tied the game with a field goal on that drive before going on to win 10-3. Geeze the moron Raider fans really come out over the tuck rule. The owners abolished the rule with a 291 vote, with Pittsburgh Steelers the only team to vote against. Any ref that cannot see that Woodson clocked Brady in the side of the head causing him to lose possession should not have a job as a ref. In the 4th quarter, Raiders' cornerback Charles Woodson tackled Patriots' quarterback Tom Brady, causing what initially appeared to be a fumble that was recovered by Raiders' linebacker Greg Biekert. But they didnt win. Also, if the player has tucked the ball into his body and then loses possession, it is a fumble.[1]. "The Tuck Rule Game." The ruling: an incomplete pass. When can I drink milk after taking iron supplements. - It was 10 years ago. What in the hell caused the NFL to make up such a stupid rule in the first place? Replays showed there was no illegal contact. Nope. You must be logged in to leave a comment. And thus a valid call. @marinofreakout, you only show your total lack of football knowledge with this statement. Your reasoning is flawed because you are obviously a biased patriot fan who enjoyed rodney harrision and his cheap shots. Well start with Brady. Players constantly diving after fumbles or incomplete passes. My problem being they didn't even enforce it right against us, Brady has completed his pass motion, he is not in the middle of it. Game was over and every player on the Raiders sideline was celebrating the victory only to be thrown back onto the field to win a game they had already won. Its just like that asinine interpretation about end-zone catches requiring a Football Move after the catch to be ruled a completion. Look at old game film highlights and you will never see a catch overturned that way. He hit Brady HARD on the helmet and face mask.. That is why his helmet was sideways and also WHY the fumble happened in the first place It should have been roughing the passerPlain and simle.. The New England Patriots were hosting the then Oakland Raiders in the 2001 AFC Divisional Playoff game. And referees were still left to judge whether or not a quarterback made an 'intentional' forward movement with their arm. New England ended up advancing into field goal range and an Adam Vinatieri 45-yard field goal sent the game into overtime. So what would have changed? at Foxboro Stadium, Foxborough, Massachusetts. are you still mad because Seymour loosened up your fat schnozz for the Ravens to bust it open like a pinata at a bday party?? Three plays later, Antowain Smith picked up eight yards for a first down at the Oakland 9 and the Patriots, now going against the wind, fought to set up the game-winning kick. Vinny Testaverde drops back to pass and arm comes forward and he loses the ball. section: | slug: tom-brady-admits-controversial-tuck-rule-game-play-might-have-been-a-fumble-and-not-an-incomplete-pass | sport: football | route: article_single.us | On the play following the incomplete pass the Patsies would pull the same trick by having Brady take a hit on a pump-fake. The ball should not have to be loose in the act of passing for it to be ruled incomplete. Brady had no intention of throwing the ball!!! You obviously have watched enough sports to know that there is a such thing called a momentum swing right? It was a pump fake that he brought back to his body. NFL Rule 3, Section 22, Article 2, and Note 2 were stated. It should have been inconclusive. In the closing moments of the fourth quarter of the game in a snowy Foxboro Stadium, with New England trailing by three points, New England quarterback Tom Brady dropped back to pass. . Dip up, Hyacinth bulbs contain oxalic acid, which is poisonous. Im sure its no consolation to the many Raiders fans around the country.. I am sure the rest of the world is a better place after seeing your post above. A few plays later, Raiders defensive back Johnnie Harris intercepted a pass from Brady on the Patriots 41-yard line, but New England's defense managed to force a punt, which would be the final result of every following drive from either team until the end of the half. And as I said in my earlier post, the Pats lost a game earlier that year against the Jets I believe it was because of the tuck rule being called in their favor. Before I continue, yes, the Tuck Rule made the difference in that game, for all of you Patriot fans out there. This solution also solves intentional grounding. If they had called roughing the passer when Woodson gave Brady a forearm shiver to the side of the head like they should have the Raiders fans would have had to find something else to complain about for the last 9 years.